This page is maintained by Persona Associates
Northumberland
Windfarms Public Inquiry Home
Last Modified: 23 December 2008
Northumberland (Green Rigg / Ray / Steadings) Windfarms Public Inquiry
Proofs of Evidence & associated Witness documents
AVIATION PARTIES
LATEST MODIFICATIONS TO PAGE SHOWN IN YELLOW HIGHLIGHT
. RETURN TO OBJECTORS INDEX PAGE
|
Document Number |
Documents available to view have bold Document Numbers. Click the relevant Document Number to view. |
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
(i) PROOFS OF EVIDENCE AND ASSOCIATED WITNESS DOCUMENTS
|
Proof of Evidence - Julian Chafer, Head of Safeguarding, Defence Estates, Ministry of Defence |
|||||||||||||
|
Rebuttal Proof of Evidence - Julian Chafer |
|||||||||||||
| MOD/1/3 | Documents referred to in Proof of Evidence (MOD/1/1) (Note: file over 6MB) | ||||||||||||
| MOD/1/4 | Supplementary Proof of Evidence re. paragraph 50 of Rebuttal Proof (MOD/1/2) | ||||||||||||
| MOD/1/5 | Second Supplementary Proof re. RAF Spadeadam’s EWTR threat radar systems | ||||||||||||
|
Proof of Evidence - Squadron Leader Colin Deane, RAF HQ Air Command ATC Aerodrome Infrastructure & Safeguarding |
|||||||||||||
| MOD/2/1A | Summary Proof of Evidence | ||||||||||||
| MOD/2/2 | Documents referred to in MOD/2/1 (MOD/2/2 (1) to MOD2/2 (3) | ||||||||||||
| MOD/2/3 | Rebuttal Proof of Evidence - Squadron Leader Colin Deane | ||||||||||||
| MOD/2/3A | Summary of Rebuttal Proof of Evidence (MOD/2/3) | ||||||||||||
|
Proof of Evidence - Mark Spencer, ATC Radar Systems Specialist, Ministry of Defence |
|||||||||||||
| MOD/3/1A | Summary Proof of Evidence | ||||||||||||
|
MOD/3/2 |
|
||||||||||||
| MOD/3/3 | “References” Documents A and D referred to MOD/3/1 | ||||||||||||
| MOD/3/4 | Rebuttal Proof of Evidence - Mark Spencer | ||||||||||||
| MOD/3/5 | Appendix 1 to Rebuttal Proof (MOD/3/4) - assessment of existing windfarms within line of sight to RAF Spadeadam watchman radar systems | ||||||||||||
| MOD/3/6 | Appendix 2 to Rebuttal Proof (MOD/3/4) - feasibility assessment of the possible tilt options for the RAF Spadeadam watchman radar systems | ||||||||||||
| MOD/3/7 | Summary of Rebuttal Proof of Evidence (MOD/3/4) | ||||||||||||
| MOD/3/8 | Supplementary Proof of Evidence – re. MOD Threat Radar File (MOD/3/9) | ||||||||||||
| MOD/3/9 | MOD Threat Radar File - Documents 1 to 38 (Documents contained in two Adobe PDF files: Documents 1 to 16 (1.4 MB) and Documents 17 to 38 (2.4 MB)) | ||||||||||||
| MOD/3/10 | DVD of a VHS video showing clips from threat radar trial | ||||||||||||
| MOD/3/11 | MOD File documents relating to the 1996 Blinkbonny Height Windfarm Inquiry Documents contained in three Adobe PDF files: Documents 1 to 11 (1.6 MB); Documents 12 to 20 (2.2 MB) and Documents 21 to 24 (1.7 MB) | ||||||||||||
| MOD/4/1 | Proof of Evidence – Squadron Leader Andrew Coleman, Range Controller, EWTR, RAF Spadeadam | ||||||||||||
| MOD/4/2 | Rebuttal Proof of Evidence - Squadron Leader Andrew Coleman, Range Controller, EWTR, RAF Spadeadam | ||||||||||||
| MOD/5/1 | Proof of Evidence – Sgt William Edmond, Instructor & Technical Manager, RAF Spadeadam | ||||||||||||
| MOD/5/2 | Appendices to Proof: App A – Basic Threat Theory Part 1A; App B – Basic Threat Theory Part 3A; App C – Moving Target Indication | ||||||||||||
| MOD/5/3 | Rebuttal Proof of Evidence – Sgt William Edmond, Instructor & Technical Manager, RAF Spadeadam |
(ii) OTHER DOCUMENTS SUBMITTED
|
Opening Statement Ministry of Defence – Philip Coppel, 4-5 Gray’s Inn Square |
|||||||||
|
Letter dated 17 January 2008 Julian Chafer, Defence Estates/Roger Claxton, Programme Officer re. AMEC’s position at Special Procedural Meeting |
|||||||||
|
Reply to AMEC/0/50 |
|||||||||
| MOD/0/4 | Letter dated 30 July 2001 from Headquarters Strike Command, RAF, High Wycombe to DE Central Safeguarding, Sutton Coldfield | ||||||||
| MOD/0/5 | "Report to the Congressional Defense Committees - The Effect of Windmill Farms On Military Readiness 2006 - Department of Defense, United States of America, Office of the Director of Defense Research and Engineering" | ||||||||
| MOD/0/6 | Reported Infringements - Yearly Comparisons | ||||||||
| MOD/0/7 | 2007 Infringements – 2007 Data – Total Reports | ||||||||
| MOD/0/8 | Extract (Section B.5) “Wind Farms Impact on Radar Aviation Interests – Final Report, QinetiQ, September 2003 | ||||||||
| MOD/0/9 | Seven coloured maps showing sites of windfarms within a 5 nautical miles band in relation to Otterburn and Spadeadam Ranges and Newcastle Control Zone | ||||||||
| MOD/0/10 | Statement of Case – Addendum (dated 14th March 2008) | ||||||||
| MOD/0/11 | RAF, Signals Engineering Establishment, Henlow letter dated 3 June 1998 re. Engineering Study to assess the Effects of Wind Farms on EW Equipment | ||||||||
| MOD/0/12 | Ministry of Defence – details from website entitled “Low Flying Area 12” with details of “Low Flying Hours Booked per Year” together with document entitled “ANNEX A The Amount of Low Flying Training by LFA (excluding dedicated user areas)” | ||||||||
| MOD/0/13 | Executive Summary “Wind Farms Impact on Radar Aviation Interests – Final Report, QinetiQ, September 2003 | ||||||||
| MOD/0/14 | Threat Radar Statement on 7th May 2008 (Inquiry Day 30) | ||||||||
| MOD/0/15 | Website Document entitled: “Combat-Like Training at the Electronic Warfare Training Facility”, Grostenquin France | ||||||||
| MOD/0/16 | Questions Arising From The Visit To The Electronic Warfare and Tactics Range RAF Spadeadam on 24 April 2008 | ||||||||
| MOD/0/17 | Annotated version of Specimen Post Mission Report provided at visit to RAF Spadeadam on 24 April 2008 | ||||||||
| MOD/0/18 | MoD Statements in relation to proposed Blinkbonny Windfarm, Newcastleton, Scottish Borders and Report to Border Wind re. windfarm and military low flying (August 1996) (First Page Only) | ||||||||
| MOD/0/19 | RAF Spadeadam – Movement Statistics | ||||||||
| MOD/0/20 | OS Map of Area showing sites of proposed windfarms, Threat Systems Locations, Newcastle Control Zone and Spadeadam & Otterburn Ranges | ||||||||
| MOD/0/21 | ETWR – Off Base Site Statistics 2006/2007 | ||||||||
| MOD/0/21A | Notes to accompany MOD/0/21 | ||||||||
| MOD/0/22 | Memorandum of Understanding – Aviation Radar and Wind Turbines (Mitigation Issues) | ||||||||
| MOD/0/22A | Aviation Plan – In respect to the interaction of wind turbines and aviation interests – 9 June 2008 (document referred to in MOD/0/22) | ||||||||
| MOD/0/23 | Grid References supplied for MOD/0/20 (OS Map of Area) | ||||||||
| MOD/0/24 | MoD response to AMEC/0/71 | ||||||||
| MOD/0/24A | MoD letter dated 23 June with responses to questions raised during Inquiry Week 13 (17th to 20th June 2008) | ||||||||
| MOD/0/25 | Airspace-Flight Procedures | ||||||||
| MOD/0/26 | Series of emails July 2008 RAF Spadeadam/Polygone | ||||||||
| MOD/0/27 | Revised list of all current Spadeadam Threat Sites | ||||||||
| MOD/0/28 |
EWTR – Off Base Site Statistics 2006/2007 Updated 21 July 2008 |
||||||||
| MOD/0/29 |
Computer screen printouts of missions |
||||||||
| MOD/0/29A |
Further
information and Post Mission Reports associated with screenshots in
MOD/0/29 [File
Size 3.34MB. Also available below in separate files]
MoD 22nd August 2008 covering and explanatory letter of each Post Mission Report (PMR)
|
||||||||
| MOD/0/30 |
Series of emails Chafer/Coleman/Coppel 12th – 14th March 2008 with extracts of Computer Application Services website pages |
||||||||
| MOD/0/31 | MOD’s Request for Reconsideration of Inspector's Ruling Made 23 July 2008 (Inspector's Ruling Inquiry Document X/25 refers) | ||||||||
| MOD/0/32 | MOD’s Reply to AMEC/0/74 and WPD/0/19 (re. Inspector's Ruling reconsideration request) | ||||||||
| MOD/0/33 | Draft List of Legal Authorities which may be relied upon by the Ministry of Defence | ||||||||
| MOD/0/34 |
Email dated 14 March 2008 to RAF Spadeadam with windfarm developments information and map |
||||||||
| MOD/0/35 | MoD response on DCLG Circular 02/2006 re. award of costs | ||||||||
| MOD/0/36 | 2007-2008 low flying stats for the UK (updated version of MOD/0/12) [2.2 MB] | ||||||||
| MOD/0/37 |
Closing Submissions on behalf of the Ministry of Defence [3 MB] |
||||||||
| MOD/0/38 | Submission on behalf the Ministry of Defence on Costs Applications against the Ministry of Defence | ||||||||
| MOD/0/38A | Bundle of Authorities referred to in MOD/0/38 |
(i) PROOFS OF EVIDENCE AND ASSOCIATED WITNESS DOCUMENTS
|
Proof of Evidence - Mark Asquith, Head of Policy and Standards |
|
| NATS/1/1A | Summary Proof of Evidence |
|
Appendix to Proof Note:
Version - |
|
|
Appendix to Proof Note: Version - JPG file |
|
| NATS/2/1 | Proof of Evidence - Anne Isaac, Head of Human Performance in Operational Safety |
| NATS/2/1A | Summary Proof of Evidence |
| NATS/3/1 | Proof of Evidence - Jason Strong, Deputy Engineering Manager, Surveillance |
| NATS/3/1A | Summary Proof of Evidence |
| NATS/3/2 | Appendix A to Proof |
| NATS/3/3 | Rebuttal Proof of Evidence - Jason Strong |
| NATS/4/1 | Proof of Evidence - Doug Maclean, ATC Watch Manager, Scottish & Oceanic ATC Centre, Prestwick |
| NATS/4/1A | Summary Proof of Evidence |
| NATS/4/2 | Appendices to Proof |
(ii) OTHER DOCUMENTS SUBMITTED
|
Opening Statement of NATS (En-route) Plc – James Strachan, 4-5 Gray’s Inn Square |
|
| NATS/0/2 | Paper entitled: “The incidence and relevance of non transponding aircraft in incidents in UK airspace” with Airprox Report Nos. 2/03; 33/99; and 198/04 |
| NATS/0/3 | Precognition Statement of K Fulton to the proposed Kyle Windfarm Inquiry (Cover) |
| NATS/0/4 | Assessment of Claxby coverage of the L602 airway |
| NATS/0/5 | “Engineering and Programmes – Technical and Operational Assessment of Proposed Development at Green Rigg Fell”, NATS (en-route) plc, August 2007 |
|
Antenna Pattern Diagram |
|
| NATS/0/7 | Lowther to Ardrossan path profile |
| NATS/0/8 | Great Dun Fell to Green Rigg path profile |
| NATS/0/9 | Ardrossan video clip |
| NATS/0/10 | Evaluation Dataset Loading Scatter diagram |
| NATS/0/11 | DVD of 'simulations' of the three developments |
| NATS/0/11A | Note in letter dated 2 May 2008 setting out contents of DVD (NATS/0/11) |
| NATS/0/12 | Analysis of Traffic Routing Between TLA and New (both ways) – 2007 |
| NATS/0/13 | UK AIP: ENR 1.1.5 – Airspace Restrictions, Danger Areas and Hazards to Flights (ENR 1.1 General Rules) |
| NATS/0/14 | Technical and Operational Assessment of Proposed Development at Green Rigg Fell, National Air Traffic Services Limited, 29/11/06 |
| NATS/0/15 | Letter dated 21 November 2007 from Wind Prospect to NATS, Prestwick |
| NATS/0/16 | NATS Note supporting the submission of Ray / Steadings / Green Rigg Blanking Assessment (with spreadsheet attached) |
| NATS/0/17 | Response by NERL to SWFL/0/21 |
| NATS/0/18 | Memorandum of Understanding between Scottish Area Control Centre and The SpadeadamRange Authorities (Danger Area EG D510) and HQ 3 Group |
| NATS/0/19 | Response by NERL to SWFL/0/23 - Airway and Upper Air Route traffic figures supplied to the Northumberland Public Inquiry |
| NATS/0/20 | Response to SWFL/0/31 by NATS (En Route)PLC ("NERL") |
| NATS/0/21 | Response to Inspector's Request for Legal Authority which may be used in Closing Submissions |
| NATS/0/22 | Closing Submissions of NATS (En-route) Plc |
| NATS/0/22A | Bundle of Legal Authorities referred to in Closing Submission (NATS/0/22) (plus covering note listing documents in bundle) [Covering note only on website] |
NEWCASTLE INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LIMITED
(i) PROOFS OF EVIDENCE AND ASSOCIATED WITNESS DOCUMENTS
| NIAL/1/1 | Summary Proof of Evidence - Keith Rodgers, Manager of Air Traffic Services, Newcastle International Airport | |||||||||||||||||||||
|
Proof of Evidence - Keith Rodgers |
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
NIAL/1/3 |
|
|||||||||||||||||||||
|
NIAL/1/3 REVISED |
Appendices to Proof (revised maps) (Nos. NIAL 1; 12; 13; 14; 15) | |||||||||||||||||||||
|
Rebuttal Proof of Evidence - Keith Rodgers |
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
NIAL/1/5 |
Appendices to Rebuttal Proof - separate files NIAL16 and NIAL17 |
|||||||||||||||||||||
| NIAL/1/6 | Supplementary Rebuttal Proof - Keith Rodgers | |||||||||||||||||||||
| NIAL/1/7 | Appendices to Supplementary Proof - NIAL 18 and NIAL 19 |
(ii) OTHER DOCUMENTS SUBMITTED
|
Brief Opening Submission on behalf of Newcastle International Airport Limited – Thomas Hill, 4-5 Gray’s Inn Square |
|
| NIAL/0/2 | Rebuttal Proof of Andrew Knill (CAA) to the Kyle Planning Inquiry (Cover) |
| NIAL/0/3 | Precognition Statement of Andrew Knill to the proposed Kyle Windfarm Inquiry (Cover) |
| NIAL/0/4 | Precognition Statement of Kenneth James to the proposed Kyle Windfarm Inquiry (Cover) |
| NIAL/0/5 | Website copy of OS “Get-a-map” – windfarms in vicinity of Hare Hill |
| NIAL/0/6 | Submissions for Glasgow Prestwick Airport |
| NIAL/0/7 | Newcastle LARS Statistics 2007 |
| NIAL/0/8 | Response to cross-examination assertion by Mr. K. James (document with examples from Appendix to SWFL/8/5) (Front Page Only) |
| NIAL/0/9 | Letter from the Royal Air Force dated 2 June 08 to Mr Keith Rodgers, Manager Air Traffic Services, Newcastle International Airport |
| NIAL/0/10 | Proposed Aviation Condition |
| NIAL/0/11 | Closing Submissions on behalf of Newcastle International Airport Limited |
LATEST MODIFICATIONS TO PAGE SHOWN IN YELLOW HIGHLIGHT
RETURN TO OBJECTORS INDEX PAGE
RETURN TO INQUIRY DOCUMENTS PAGE
Help on viewing documents
For viewing Adobe PDF files, please click here
to download
the Reader.
If
you do not have Microsoft Word, the Microsoft Word Viewer lets you
open Word 2003 documents and documents created with all previous versions
of Microsoft Word for Windows® and Microsoft Word for Macintosh.
Click
here for free download.