This page is maintained by Persona Associates

Humberhead Levels Windfarms Inquiry
(Keadby and Tween Bridge) - Respondees' Documents

Objectors Proofs of Evidence RETURN TO OBJECTORS INDEX

Document Number

Documents available to view have bold Document Numbers. Click the relevant Document Number to view.

CPRE South Yorkshire

(i) PROOFS OF EVIDENCE AND ASSOCIATED WITNESS DOCUMENTS

CPRE/1/1	Proof of Evidence Dr Andrew Tickle
CPRE/1/2	Leaflet entitled “Saving tranquil places” (Yorkshire and the Humber )
CPRE/1/3	Extract of tranquillity map covering Tween Bridge site and local areas

(ii) OTHER DOCUMENTS SUBMITTED

CPRE/0/1	Larger scale copy of tranquillity map area (CPRE/1/3 refers) covering Tween Bridge site showing turbine sites numbered 1, 12 and 22
CPRE/0/2	Additional written representation in relation to Tween Bridge, with five appendices

(i) PROOFS OF EVIDENCE AND ASSOCIATED WITNESS DOCUMENTS

PRP/1/1	Not allotted (see TDWAG 7/ series)
PRP/1/2	Policy Summary
PRP/1/3	Submission on Law
PRP/1/4	Topic: Noise – Evidence of Peter Pennington
PRP/1/5	Topic: Noise – Appendix 1 to the Evidence of Peter Pennington
PRP/1/6	Topic: Noise – Appendix 2 to the Evidence of Peter Pennington
PRP/2/1	Proof of Evidence on Noise – Mr R A Davis, Robert Davis Associates
PRP/2/2	Appendices 1 to 3 and Figures 1 and 2 to Proof PRP/2/1
PRP/2/3	Rebuttal Proof of Evidence
PRP/2/4	Summary Proof of Evidence
PRP/3/1	Evidence of Peter Richard Pennington on Landscape and Planning

(ii) OTHER DOCUMENTS SUBMITTED

PRP/0/1	Bushell and another v Secretary of State for the Environment (All England Law Reports [1980] pages 608 to 633)
PRP/0/2	Opening Statement by P R Pennington on the topic of Noise
PRP/0/3	DTI Summary – Low Frequency Noise Report and (extract) Executive Summary of “The Measurement of low frequency noise at three UK wind farms”.
PRP/0/4	eftec “The Overview of Valuation of Visual Impacts of Transmission Price Control Review (TPCR)”, Final Report, Ofgem, 22 March 2006 (revised version: 1 June 2006)
PRP/0/5	Paper on Noise Conditions from Mr R A Davis, Robert Davis Associates
PRP/0/5A	Covering letter dated 8 June 2007 to the paper (PRP/0/5) on Noise Conditions from Mr R A Davis, Robert Davis Associates
PRP/0/6	Note on Sustainability in support of draft proposals for Planning Conditions
PRP/0/7	Extract from “Peat, Carbon Dioxide Payback and Wind Farms”, Dr M J Hall, (Renewable Energy Foundation)
PRP/0/8	Closing Submission on the Topic of Noise

CF/1/1 (23/1)	Letter dated 19 January 2007 enclosing submission to Inquiry as MP for Don Valley
CF/1/2 (16/1)	Submission as presented to Inquiry on 16^th February 2007

IC/1/1	Proof of Evidence entitled “Local views and perspectives”
IC/1/2 (29/1)	Letter to the Inspector dated 26 January 2007 concerning construction access routes

IP series

IP/0	Initial document list
IP/1	Department of Trade & Industry letter dated 10 September 1993 (see also NAAW/0/1)
IP/2	The Housing Health and Safety Rating System (England) Regulations 2005 (S.I. 2005/3208)
IP/3	Explanatory Memorandum to S.I. 2005/3208 (Inquiry Document IP/2)
IP/4	Explanatory Memorandum to The Environmental Noise (England) Regulations 2006
IP/5	Two photographs – Strawson Farms, Extraction and pumping station
IP/6	Noise and Sleep – page from the World Health Organisation (WHO) website
IP/7	Report on the third meeting on night noise guidelines – Lisbon April 2005 (WHO)
IP/8	“Farmers Weekly” news item ‘Wind farm noise is driving us out of our house’ supporting DVD of BBC “Look North” (shown to inquiry)
IP/9	Letter dated 25^th January 2007 re. Inquiry evening session on 25/01/07 at Seven Lakes, Ealand, Crowle
IP/10	Note on turbines in view of relative windows at North Pilfrey Farmhouse
IP/11	Proof of Evidence and Appendices presented on 7th June 2007

PH/1	Statement re. Noise, Shadow Flicker, Visual Intrusion and Landscape, Water Contamination
PH/2	Letter enclosing photograph dated 14 February 2007 regarding Mr Christopher Clarke’s submission (EON/2/1)
PH/3	Email dated 11/06/07 setting out final points
PH/4	Email dated 15/06/07 re. water supply at Medge Hall

JPW/0	Statement re. illegal inclusion of land owned and other matters (plus supporting documents numbered JPW/1 to JPW/12)
JPW/0/1	Planning Inspectorate decision letter dated 25 January 2000 re. The Doncaster Borough Council Byway Open to All Traffic (Thorne Moors) Definitive Map Modification Order 1997 and The Doncaster Borough Council Footpath (Thorne Moors) Definitive Map Modification Order 1997 (Final Decision)
JPW/0/2	Planning Inspectorate decision letter dated 25 June 1999 re. The Doncaster Borough Council Byway Open to All Traffic (Thorne Moors) Definitive Map Modification Order 1997 and The Doncaster Borough Council Footpath (Thorne Moors) Definitive Map Modification Order 1997

WR/1/1

AW/1/1	Letter dated 4^th February 2007 re. cumulative effects of windfarms in the Humberhead Levels area.
AW/0	Paper entitled “Considering the cumulative implications” by Dr Ann Walker
AW/0/1	Note re. existence of a number of wind farm proposals at various stages of preparation in the Isle of Axholme/Humberhead Levels area of North Lincolnshire and the East Riding of Yorkshire, Licensing and Consents Unit, Department of Trade and Industry
AW/0/2	ELSEVIER – Energy Policy paper: “Community perspective of wind energy in Australia…”
AW/0/3	Extract from National Parks and Access to the Countryside Act 1949: Part III Section 15 Meaning of “nature reserve”
AW/0/4	ELSEVIER – Science Direct: “Wind power implementation:……..”

JD/1	Letter dated 12^th January 2007 from Julian T Davis and S Jane Davis re. the evidence of Nicholas Watts MBE (for Friends of Tween Bridge – Inquiry Documents FOT/4 and FOT/4/1 below refer).
JD/1/1	Photographs, analysis of noise at Deeping St Nicholas wndfarm diagrams, plans, etc. (from Microsoft Powerpoint presentation to Inquiry)
JD/1/2	Email dated 3 May 2007 from Jane Davis responding to RES/0/17
JD/1/3	Email dated 24 May 2007 from Jane Davis with regard to confirmation from DEFRA about undertaking intensive tests at their property at Deeping St Nicholas
JD/1/4	Email dated 31 May 2007 enclosing copy of Notes of Meeting of DTI Noise Working Group held on Monday 23 April 2007

RB/1

Letters dated 16/3/06 to DTi and 17/2/04 to Doncaster MBC

DSAN/1